The Question

Aircraft releasing cloud seeding flares into storm clouds above an arid landscape

In 2018, an Iranian general stood at a podium and accused Israel of stealing Iran's clouds. The claim was scientifically shaky — Iran's own meteorologists winced — but the instinct behind it was ahead of its time. Because upwind of every thirsty country, someone now really is flying planes into clouds and squeezing them for rain. The technology is called cloud seeding: aircraft or ground generators release tiny particles, usually silver iodide, that give water vapour something to cling to, so droplets grow heavy enough to fall. It does not create weather from nothing. It redirects what was already in the sky — and the sky does not stop at borders.

When Dubai flooded in April 2024, after a record downpour, the first question online was not about climate change. It was: did the seeding planes do this? The UAE's National Center of Meteorology said seeding flights had taken place on the Sunday and Monday but not during the storm itself, and meteorologists said the floods were caused by an unusually strong low-pressure system. But the fact that the question was asked, instantly and everywhere, shows how politically charged weather modification has become. The question our forecast addresses is when the first formal international fight over engineered weather lands in front of a global institution.

What the Evidence Shows

The scale is no longer experimental. In December 2020, China's cabinet said it would extend its artificial rain and snow programme to cover at least 5.5 million square kilometres by 2025, with work in areas including the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, and reach an "advanced" level of weather modification by 2035. The UAE runs one of the world's most active cloud-seeding programmes. In the American West, Utah, Idaho, and other states fund seeding to boost winter snowpack. Meanwhile, the politics in some places are moving the other way: Tennessee banned geoengineering in 2024, and in 2025 Florida passed a law making unauthorised weather modification a felony, a push partly fuelled by "chemtrail" conspiracy theories.

The legal architecture, meanwhile, is a museum piece. The only binding treaty is ENMOD, signed in 1977, which bans using environmental modification as a weapon of war. It has never been tested in court, says nothing about peacetime "rain competition" between neighbours, and predates every technology now in use. There is no international rule that stops one country seeding a weather system before it crosses into the next country — and no agreed science for proving harm if it does.

"China wants to boost its ability to modify the weather and will extend an artificial rain and snow program to cover at least 5.5 million square kilometres of land by 2025."

— Reuters, December 2020

And the accusations have already begun — rhetorically. In 2018 an Iranian general accused Israel and another country of stealing Iran's clouds, a claim that Iran's own meteorological officials dismissed. But rhetoric is not litigation. To bring a case before the International Court of Justice or another global body, a state would need evidence that a neighbour's seeding caused measurable harm, and the science of attribution is weak: rigorous studies generally find seeding adds modest amounts of precipitation, under the right conditions, and proving where that water would otherwise have fallen is very hard.

For all of human history, the rain fell on whoever it fell on. That era is ending — and nobody signed anything.

Why This Is Happening

Water scarcity is turning the atmosphere into contested territory. The coming decades are forecast to put billions of people under water stress. When the river is empty, the only water left is the water in the sky — and unlike rivers, atmospheric moisture has no treaties, no gauging stations, and no history of shared management. Desperation plus capability is how every resource conflict starts.

The technology is cheap enough for many. A cloud-seeding programme costs millions, not billions — affordable for any government facing drought — which is why dozens of countries run one. Low cost means wide adoption, and wide adoption means more overlapping operations on shared weather systems. But overlapping operations have so far produced complaints and suspicion, not formal cases.

Something much bigger is coming up behind it. Cloud seeding is the modest cousin of solar geoengineering — schemes to cool the whole planet by spraying reflective particles into the upper atmosphere. A startup called Make Sunsets has already launched unauthorised sulphur balloons, prompting Mexico to ban solar geoengineering outright. Once private actors and lone states can touch the global thermostat, the pressure for international governance becomes irresistible — and cloud seeding disputes are the natural first case to force the issue.


What Could Happen

A rain dispute reaches a global body by 2033 Possible · 15%

A drought-stricken state formally accuses an upwind neighbour of moisture theft and files a complaint at the UN, the International Court of Justice, or another global body by 2033. The science of attribution proves murky and the case drags, but it forces the first real negotiation over atmospheric water rights.

Quiet diplomacy keeps it out of the courtroom Most likely · 60%

Tensions over weather modification rise, but governments manage them through regional agreements, codes of conduct, and quiet diplomacy, as with most water disputes. Weak attribution science makes a formal case hard to win, so none reaches a global body by 2033. Solar geoengineering, a much bigger issue, eventually forces global rules instead.

The science deflates the conflict Possible · 25%

Rigorous studies conclude cloud seeding adds only single-digit percentages of precipitation — too little to steal, too little to fight over. Programs persist as political theatre and drought insurance, but "rain theft" claims collapse under peer review, and the first great weather lawsuit waits for technologies that actually work at scale.

Our Assessment
We assign 15% probability — unlikely that a formal international dispute over weather modification reaches a global body by 2033. We have lowered this forecast from 58%. Our earlier version included a quote from an "International Environmental Law Review" and reports of disputes we could not verify. The ingredients for tension are real: large programmes in China and the UAE, shrinking water supplies, and an old treaty, ENMOD, that only covers military use. But accusations so far have stayed political, and states rarely file cases they cannot evidence — and proving that a neighbour took your rain is scientifically very hard.

What Can We Do

Diplomats studying an atmospheric moisture map of contested cross-border weather systems

Weather modification sounds like a problem for foreign ministries, but its consequences — water prices, food prices, insurance, regional stability — will reach every household. Awareness now is leverage later.

Learn what your own region is doing to its sky. If you live in the American West, your state may already fund seeding; Utah publishes its program openly. Knowing whether your snowpack is partly engineered changes how you read every drought headline — and every neighbouring state's complaint.

Support attribution science, the unglamorous key to everything. The ability to measure what seeding actually does is the difference between paranoia and policy. Public funding for atmospheric research — and open data requirements on national programs — deserves the same civic support as any water infrastructure.

Push for transparency rules before the first crisis. A simple international registry — who is seeding, where, when — would defuse most accusations before they become incidents. Citizens' groups pressing for notification agreements now will look prescient by 2033.

Watch the geoengineering debate with clear eyes. The cloud seeding disputes are the rehearsal. When solar geoengineering proposals reach parliaments — and they will — the governance frameworks built or neglected in the seeding era will decide whether humanity manages its thermostat deliberately or chaotically. Vote accordingly.