The Question

Shelves of leafy greens growing under pink-purple LED light inside a supermarket produce section

The lettuce in your refrigerator has had a harder week than you have. It was probably cut in California or Spain, washed in chlorinated water, sealed in plastic, trucked to a distribution centre, trucked again, flown if it was unlucky, and shelved — roughly 2,000 miles and five to ten days after harvest. By the time it reaches your plate, it has lost much of its vitamin content and most of its will to live.

Now picture the produce aisle in 2031. Against the back wall stands a glass column, glowing softly pink, where rows of butterhead lettuce sit growing under LED light. A staff member harvests your salad while you pick out tomatoes. It has travelled nine metres. Shoppers in some European stores bought greens this way during the in-store farming boom of the early 2020s. The question is whether the farm-in-a-store can come back from the bust and become normal.

What the Evidence Shows

Vertical farming — stacking crops in trays under artificial light, indoors, year-round — has already had its boom and its bust. The Berlin start-up Infarm placed grow-cabinets inside supermarkets including Kroger, Marks & Spencer, and Metro across many countries at its peak. Plenty, backed by nearly $1 billion from investors including SoftBank, Walmart, and Jeff Bezos, struck a partnership with Walmart. And Oishii, growing Japanese omakase strawberries in a New Jersey warehouse, showed that shoppers will pay a premium when indoor produce tastes better.

Then came the winter. AeroFarms, which had raised more than $300 million, filed for bankruptcy protection in 2023, as did AppHarvest. Infarm retreated from most of its markets. Bowery Farming, once valued at over $2 billion, ceased operations in November 2024, and Plenty filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in March 2025. Cheap money had funded large farms with large electricity bills, and when interest rates rose the arithmetic failed. The survivors are smaller, more focused businesses, mostly selling premium crops — but the in-store model in particular has largely retreated.

"Vertical farming has proved to be a tough category, with both AeroFarms and AppHarvest filing for bankruptcy protection."

— TechCrunch, reporting Bowery Farming's shutdown, November 2024

The underlying advantages never went away. Indoor farms can use far less water than field agriculture, need few or no pesticides, and are untouched by drought, frost, or field contamination. LED lighting keeps getting more efficient. But electricity remains the biggest cost, and for cheap, bulky crops like lettuce, sunlight is free. Countries short of land and water, such as Singapore and the Gulf states, have backed indoor farming for food security, where the economics are different. In the US and Europe, where outdoor greens are cheap and plentiful most of the year, indoor farms have found it much harder to compete on anything but premium crops.

Your salad currently commutes further than you do. That is not a law of nature — it is a rounding error waiting to be deleted.

Why This Is Happening

Freshness is the one thing the old supply chain cannot fake. Leafy greens lose flavour and nutrients from the moment they are cut, and a lettuce harvested in front of you is a different product from one harvested last week. Grocers, fighting for any edge, get a theatre piece and a premium product in one glowing box — if they can make it pay.

Small and close is the remaining hope. The failed giants built farms the size of aircraft hangars and still had to truck the produce. In-store and store-adjacent units cut transport, cold storage, and spoilage. But they add labour, maintenance, and food-safety work inside stores whose margins are thin, and the in-store pioneer Infarm itself pulled back.

Climate chaos is making outdoor lettuce a gamble. Droughts in the American Southwest and Spain — which grow most of the Western world's winter greens — have repeatedly spiked prices and emptied shelves. Retailers hate empty shelves more than they hate electricity bills. A farm indoors delivers the same crop, every week of the year, regardless of what the sky is doing.


What Could Happen

Store-grown greens become a standard premium category by 2031 Unlikely · 10%

Major chains roll out in-store towers and small farms behind or beside their stores, and the "harvested today" shelf becomes a fixture in most large supermarkets in wealthy cities by 2031.

Regional hub farms win instead of in-store units Most likely · 65%

The in-store cabinet proves too fiddly and costly, and retailers instead buy from a smaller number of indoor farms a few miles away, mainly for herbs, salad mixes, and premium berries. Indoor-grown produce remains a niche on the shelf, while field farming supplies most greens.

Energy prices strangle the category again Possible · 25%

A sustained spike in electricity prices — or a failure of LED efficiency to keep improving — pushes indoor greens permanently into luxury territory. Vertical farming survives in Japan, the Gulf states, and Singapore, where land and water scarcity justify the cost, but Western supermarkets quietly unplug the towers.

Our Assessment
We assign 10% probability — unlikely that by 2031, greens grown in or immediately beside the supermarket are a mainstream category in wealthy markets. We have lowered this forecast from 71%. Our earlier version included a quote from a "Journal of Agricultural Economics" we could not verify, and it listed Plenty as a survivor — in fact it filed for bankruptcy in 2025, after Bowery shut down in 2024. The industry's collapse, not its comeback, is the main evidence so far, and the in-store model has largely retreated. Indoor farming will survive for premium crops; store-grown salad going mainstream within five years would require a sharp reversal.

What Can We Do

A shopper choosing living lettuce with intact roots from an illuminated in-store growing cabinet

This is one forecast you can taste-test today, and your choices at the shelf genuinely shape how fast it arrives.

Buy the living lettuce and judge for yourself. Many supermarkets already sell hydroponic greens with roots attached — often grown regionally indoors. Compare flavour and fridge life against the bagged stuff. If it wins in your kitchen, that purchase is a vote retailers count with great precision.

Read the label for miles, not just organic. "Organic" says how it was grown; it says nothing about the ten-day truck ride. Look for harvest dates and grower locations. Produce harvested this week within 100 miles — indoor or outdoor — is almost always the fresher, better product.

Expect — and question — the premium. Store-grown greens will cost more at first. Weigh it honestly: if you throw away a third of every bag of salad you buy, a longer-lasting head that costs 30% more is not actually more expensive.

Try the technology at home at countertop scale. Sub-$100 countertop hydroponic gardens grow herbs and lettuce with the same technique. It will not feed your family, but it will make you a sharper judge of the coming produce aisle — and fresh basil in January makes its own argument.