The Question
The world's first electric traffic light was switched on at the corner of Euclid Avenue and East 105th Street in Cleveland, Ohio, in 1914. It was a brilliant solution to a specific problem: humans in fast machines cannot be trusted to negotiate an intersection by eye contact. So we built a system of coloured lamps that stops half the traffic so the other half can move — and then we accepted, for over a century, that sitting motionless at an empty crossroads is simply what driving is.
Add it up and the absurdity shows. The average urban driver loses days every year waiting at red lights, engines burning fuel to go nowhere, while the cross street sits vacant. The traffic light is not traffic management. It is a confession that vehicles cannot talk to each other. But now they can — and the question is when the first city admits that the coloured lamps, like the gas streetlight and the telephone box, have finished their work.
What the Evidence Shows
The theoretical case was made by researchers at MIT's Senseable City Lab and colleagues, in a 2016 paper in PLOS ONE. They modelled "slot-based" intersections where connected vehicles book a slot to pass through, like aircraft landing at an airport. No lights, no stopping, just continuous interleaved flow. The paper concluded that switching from traffic lights to slot-based intersections had the potential to double capacity and sharply reduce delays — a result from mathematical modelling, assuming every vehicle is automated and connected.
The practical case for smarter signals is already on the street. Carnegie Mellon's Surtrac system — adaptive signals that watch traffic in real time and re-time themselves — was reported to cut travel times by about 25% and idling by over 40% in its Pittsburgh pilot. Google's Project Green Light uses driving data to suggest better signal timings; early results from 70 intersections in 12 cities showed up to 30% fewer stops and up to 10% lower emissions. These systems make lights smarter. None of them removes the lights.
"An intersection is a difficult place, because you have two flows competing for the same piece of real estate."
— Carlo Ratti, MIT Senseable City Lab, 2016There is even a low-tech preview. Dutch towns pioneering "shared space" urbanism removed signals, signs, and kerbs from town centres, forcing everyone to negotiate by attention rather than obedience. Drachten in the Netherlands became the famous case, where a busy junction without lights was reported to flow better with fewer crashes. But shared space works because traffic moves slowly and humans negotiate face to face — the opposite of a high-speed machine ballet.
Your grandchildren will ask why the city made everyone stop at a lamp — and you will not have a good answer.
Why This Is Happening
The connected-car fleet is growing — slowly. Vehicle-to-everything (V2X) radios let cars broadcast position and speed to each other and to infrastructure, but they are still fitted to only a small share of vehicles, and standards have shifted repeatedly. Robotaxis navigate busy junctions in several cities, but they obey traffic lights like everyone else. A signal-free district needs nearly every vehicle — and every pedestrian crossing — to be handled by the system, which is decades away in a normal city.
Cities are desperate for capacity they cannot build. No mayor can widen downtown streets, but MIT's numbers suggest signal-free coordination could double intersection throughput using the asphalt that already exists. That is the political jackpot: congestion relief with no construction, funded by removing infrastructure rather than adding it.
The climate math is embarrassing. Idling at signals burns billions of litres of fuel a year globally and every stop-start cycle spikes emissions. Adaptive-signal pilots have already documented double-digit emission cuts from simply reducing stops. For cities with legally binding climate targets, the intersection is low-hanging fruit that gets riper every year the vehicle fleet gets smarter.
What Could Happen
A purpose-built or heavily instrumented district — a Chinese smart-city zone, a Gulf development, or an autonomous-vehicle-only core — removes signals for vehicles by 2035, keeping protected crossings for pedestrians and cyclists, and becomes a pilgrimage site for planners.
The mixed-traffic problem proves decisive: pedestrians, cyclists, and decades of old cars cannot join a machine ballet. Cities instead universalise adaptive signals that talk to connected cars — green waves timed to your arrival, near-zero pointless waits. The red light survives as a fallback for the unconnected, the way cash survives alongside cards: rarely used, never quite removed.
A signal-free pilot suffers a high-profile fatality involving a pedestrian or a hacked vehicle, and the political appetite evaporates overnight. Regulators mandate signals wherever people walk, algorithmic-priority schemes are attacked as toll roads for the rich — who gets the fast slot through the intersection? — and the concept retreats to freight ports and campuses until the 2040s.
What Can We Do
The intersection of 2035 is being designed now, in city budgets and vehicle standards. There are practical ways to benefit early and shape what arrives.
Support adaptive signals in your own city today. Systems like Surtrac and Green Light are cheap, proven, and cut your commute now. When your council debates transport budgets, smart signal retrofits deliver more time back per dollar than almost any road project — ask for them by name.
When you next buy a car, check for V2X support. Connected-vehicle features will increasingly determine which lanes, districts, and priority schemes your car can use — and its resale value into the 2030s. It is the new equivalent of buying a car with GPS in 2005.
Defend the pedestrian in every consultation. The signal-free intersection is optimised for vehicles; walkers and cyclists must be designed in, not patched in. Residents who show up to planning meetings asking one question — "how does a child cross this street?" — will shape these districts more than any lobbyist.
Ask the equity question early. When intersections become algorithms, priority becomes a product someone can sell — express slots for those who pay. Cities that ban paid priority before deployment will avoid the ugliest version of this future. Raise it before the system ships, because rules are softest at the start.