The Question
For a hundred years the referee's word was final, fallible and gloriously human. A linesman's flag could end a World Cup dream on a guess. A tennis umpire could squint at a puff of chalk and rule against the evidence of everyone's eyes. We accepted it because there was no alternative.
That is no longer true. Cameras now track the ball to the millimetre and the human body to the joint. So the question is not whether machines can officiate — in some situations they already do, better than people. The question is whether, by 2032, the algorithm delivers the verdict on most of the calls that decide matches, with human officials simply relaying it.
What the Evidence Shows
Tennis has already crossed the line. Hawk-Eye ball-tracking has been used for player challenges since the mid-2000s. In 2023 the ATP announced tour-wide electronic line calling from 2025, and the Australian Open and US Open had already replaced line judges with automated calls. Wimbledon followed in 2025, ending the use of line judges for "out" and "fault" calls while keeping chair umpires. Only the French Open, played on clay where the ball leaves a mark, still relied on human line judges at the time of Wimbledon's announcement.
"We consider the technology to be sufficiently robust and the time is right to take this important step in seeking maximum accuracy in our officiating."
— Sally Bolton, Chief Executive, All England Lawn Tennis Club, announcing electronic line calling at Wimbledon, October 2024Football is moving, but more carefully. At the 2022 World Cup, semi-automated offside technology used limb-tracking cameras and a sensor in the ball to identify offsides and produce a 3D animation within seconds. It has since been used in the Champions League, Serie A and La Liga, and the Premier League introduced it in April 2025, using about 30 cameras per stadium, after delays caused by problems in testing. Even so, VAR officials still check that the system has followed the process correctly before the referee is told. For the 2026 World Cup, FIFA's updated system alerts assistant referees when a player is more than 10 centimetres offside, rather than 50 centimetres under the old version, but the very closest margins are still decided by the officiating team.
Baseball, long officiating's great holdout, has also changed. In September 2025, MLB approved an Automated Ball-Strike challenge system for the 2026 season. Human umpires still call balls and strikes, but each team can challenge two calls a game, with the Hawk-Eye-based system ruling on the appeal. Only the pitcher, catcher or batter can trigger a review, by tapping a helmet or cap; the result appears on the stadium video board, and a team keeps its challenge if it wins. The system was tested in the minor leagues, in spring training and at the 2025 All-Star Game, and some of the players on MLB's competition committee reportedly voted against it. Cricket has used ball-tracking and edge-detection in its Decision Review System for years, though on close leg-before-wicket decisions the on-field umpire's original call still stands within a margin of error.
Machines are taking over the lines. The fouls are still ours to argue about.
Why This Is Happening
The technology is faster and more accurate than people on factual calls. Tracking systems can render an offside line in seconds and a line call almost instantly, with tiny margins of error. MLB's system, for example, uses a dozen cameras in each ballpark. Once a machine is demonstrably better at a factual call, keeping a human in charge of it becomes hard to defend.
VAR's delays strengthened the case for automation. The half-human, half-machine model frustrated many fans: long delays, repeated reviews and little information in the stadium. Faster semi-automated systems are a direct response.
Money raises the stakes of every error. A single wrong call can swing a title, a relegation or large sums in bets. Leagues, broadcasters and sponsors increasingly treat avoidable officiating errors as unacceptable.
But many decisions are judgments, not measurements. In football, the calls that decide most matches — fouls, penalties, handballs, red cards — depend on interpretation of intent and force. No current system decides them. That is the main reason "most major calls" will likely stay human in football even as offside and goal-line decisions are automated.
What Could Happen
Line calls, goal-line decisions, offside and ball-tracking reviews go fully to the machine, while fouls, handballs and dangerous play stay human. Tennis is almost fully automated; football and cricket are split. Arguments survive where meaning, not measurement, is at stake.
AI systems trained on vast video libraries begin flagging fouls and handballs reliably enough for competitions to let them decide, and cricket drops the umpire's call margin. Human officials become game managers who handle conduct and flow while algorithms deliver most verdicts.
Systems stay too expensive for most leagues, officials and some fans push back, and automation remains confined to the biggest competitions while everyday football and cricket keep human officials for nearly everything.
What Can We Do
Whether you love a correct call or mourn the loss of the pub argument, fans have more say in this shift than they may think. The question is not only whether machines decide, but how openly.
Demand transparency, not just accuracy. A machine verdict is trustworthy only if people can see how it was reached. Push leagues to show tracking animations in stadiums and on broadcasts, publish error margins and open systems to independent testing.
Protect the human role that still matters. Someone must manage flow, safety and the feel of a game, and judge intent. Support officials as game managers rather than treating them as obsolete.
Keep the argument where it belongs. Perfect factual calls need not sterilise sport. The debates machines cannot settle — tactics, selection, fouls and the greatest of all time — will remain.
Watch the betting incentives. Some of the loudest pressure for certainty comes from gambling money. Officiating should serve the sport and its fans first.
- Gulf News (AFP) — Wimbledon replaces line judges with electronic system, October 2024
- Flashscore — Wimbledon replaces line judges with electronic line-calling system
- New Straits Times (AFP) — Premier League to use semi-automated offside technology this season, April 2025
- Thairath — Advanced semi-automated offside system for the 2026 World Cup
- CBS News — MLB approves robot umpires for 2026 as part of challenge system, September 2025
- Scripps News — MLB will use robot umpires in 2026