The Question
What we are predicting is not a temporary rough patch. Not a blip caused by high interest rates that will resolve itself when the Federal Reserve cuts. What we are predicting is a structural, generational break — a point at which homeownership stops being the expected outcome of a working life and becomes instead a privilege available mainly to those who already have wealth, or whose parents do.
The specific forecast: by 2035, the homeownership rate for Americans under 40 will be below 50% — a threshold that reshapes everything from retirement security to political alignment to the way cities are built. We put the probability at 90%. The forces driving this have been building for two decades and show no sign of reversing quickly.
What the Evidence Shows
The numbers are already stark. According to Census Bureau data analysed by the National Association of Home Builders, the homeownership rate for households headed by someone under 35 fell to 35.2% in the second quarter of 2026, down from 36.4% a year earlier. For those aged 35 to 44, it was 60.9%. Because ownership rises steeply with age, the rate for everyone under 40 is almost certainly already below half. The National Association of Realtors found that first-time buyers made up a record-low 21% of home purchases in the year to June 2025, and that the typical first-time buyer was 40 years old — up from 33 just five years earlier. NAR's deputy chief economist, Jessica Lautz, noted that the first-time buyer share had roughly halved since 2007, and those who did buy put down a median of 10%, the highest since 1989.
The price-to-income ratio tells the story. Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies found that the national median home price reached 5.0 times median household income in 2024, up from 4.1 in 2019 and an average of 3.2 in the 1990s. In expensive coastal metros the ratio is far higher. With mortgage rates still well above their pandemic lows, the monthly cost of buying a typical home is far beyond what many young households can manage.
"The historically low share of first-time buyers underscores the real-world consequences of a housing market starved for affordable inventory."
— Jessica Lautz, Deputy Chief Economist, National Association of Realtors, November 2025Large investors add to the pressure in some places. They own a small share of homes nationally, but a 2024 report by the Government Accountability Office found that institutional investors had become significant owners of single-family rental homes in some fast-growing Sun Belt metros, such as Atlanta, competing with first-time buyers for starter homes.
When the typical first-time buyer is 40, homeownership is no longer the default path for people in their twenties and thirties.
Why This Is Happening
Prices have outrun incomes. Home prices have risen much faster than incomes over the past quarter-century, and the gap widened sharply during the pandemic. Closing it requires either a sustained wage boom or a sustained price correction — and existing homeowners and local governments have strong incentives to prevent the latter.
Interest rates locked the market. Mortgage rates jumped from around 3% to above 7% between 2021 and 2023. Many existing homeowners chose not to sell and give up their cheap mortgages, inventory shrank, and prices stayed high even as affordability fell to multi-decade lows. This "lock-in effect" has kept would-be buyers renting.
Zoning rules block new supply. The single most powerful driver of long-term unaffordability is the chronic underbuilding of homes in places where people want to live. Single-family zoning, height restrictions, parking minimums, and lengthy permitting processes have made it effectively illegal to build density in most American suburbs. Until those rules change at scale — and the political resistance from existing homeowners is fierce — supply cannot meet demand.
What Could Happen
Incremental zoning reforms at the state level — such as those passed in California, Montana, and Oregon — add some supply but not enough to reverse decades of underbuilding. Homeownership for under-40s stays well below half through 2035. Political pressure mounts, but reform stays piecemeal.
A combination of federal housing support, aggressive state zoning reform, and first-time buyer programmes stabilises young adult homeownership. Rates edge up, but remain below half for under-40s. This requires political will that has not materialised in two decades.
A significant recession triggers a large price correction in key metros. Affordability improves sharply and a wave of first-time buyers enters — enough to push under-40 ownership back above half. This requires economic pain that policymakers will try hard to prevent.
What Can We Do
The problem is political before it is economic. That means the most effective individual action is also the least obvious one: vote on housing, specifically.
Support zoning reform in your city. The single most powerful lever for long-term affordability is allowing more homes to be built where people want to live. When local ballot measures propose upzoning — allowing duplexes, apartments, or mixed-use buildings in areas previously restricted to single-family homes — they are directly addressing the core of this crisis.
Consider lower-cost markets intentionally. The affordability gap between the most expensive and least expensive metros has widened dramatically. Remote work has made geographic flexibility more viable for a larger share of workers. Buying in a mid-size city rather than a coastal hub is not settling — it is often a financially superior decision over any time horizon.
Build savings specifically for a down payment. Down payment assistance programmes exist at state and federal level and are chronically underused. The National Council of State Housing Agencies maintains an up-to-date database of available programmes by state. Many go unclaimed simply because eligible buyers do not know they exist.
Engage with the political debate as a voter and citizen. Housing policy is decided in planning meetings, city councils, and state legislatures — not primarily in national elections. These are the forums where the zoning rules that price people out get made, and where they can be changed.
- NAHB Eye on Housing — Homeownership rate edges down to 65% (Census HVS Q2 2026), August 2026
- US Census Bureau — Quarterly residential vacancies and homeownership, Q2 2026 (PDF)
- MPA — First-time homebuyer share hits record low as median age climbs to 40 (NAR 2025 profile)
- Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies — The State of the Nation's Housing 2025 (PDF)
- US Government Accountability Office — Housing: information on institutional investors in the single-family rental market, 2024