The Question

Young professional at a kitchen table reviewing financial statements, student loan paperwork visible

The debate over student debt is usually framed as a political question: should loans be forgiven, and if so, how much? That is the wrong frame for predicting what happens by 2035. The more useful question is whether, regardless of what reforms pass, student debt will keep acting as a drag on the financial lives of the people who carry it.

We are not predicting the absence of change. Repayment rules have already changed sharply, some borrowers will receive forgiveness through public service or long-term repayment programmes, and new limits on borrowing will shape future students. But the size of existing balances, the number of borrowers in trouble and the direction of recent policy suggest that most of today's borrowers will still feel the weight of their loans in 2035.

What the Evidence Shows

According to Federal Student Aid, 42.6 million people held federal student loans totaling about $1.7 trillion as of March 2026. Repayment problems have grown since the pandemic payment pause ended. More than 9.3 million borrowers were in default by mid-2026, owing about $234 billion. When missed payments began appearing on credit reports again in early 2025, the New York Fed found that the share of student loan balances seriously delinquent jumped from below 1% to nearly 8% in a single quarter, and it had earlier estimated that more than nine million borrowers could see significant credit score drops.

"Among borrowers who were required to make payments, nearly one in four student loan borrowers (23.7 percent) were behind on their student loans in the first quarter of 2025."

— Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Liberty Street Economics, May 2025

This is no longer only a young person's problem. The New York Fed found that for every age group over 40, at least one in four borrowers with a payment due was more than 90 days behind, and the average age of a delinquent borrower rose to 40.4. At the same time, more than 20 million federal borrowers were not in repayment at all, and another 5 million had a $0 monthly payment.

The effect on life decisions is real, though smaller than often claimed. A study by Federal Reserve economists, published in the Journal of Labor Economics, found that a $1,000 increase in student debt lowered the homeownership rate by about 1.8 percentage points for public four-year college-goers in their mid-20s — roughly a four-month delay in buying a first home. In a 2019 Federal Reserve article summarizing that work, the researchers estimated that about 20% of the decline in homeownership among young adults since 2005 could be attributed to rising student debt — important, but not the main cause. Lower credit scores from delinquency make mortgages and car loans more expensive, compounding the effect.

Student debt is not just a financial problem. It is a life-stage problem — arriving at exactly the ages when homes, families and retirement savings matter most.

Why This Is Happening

Policy has moved toward stricter repayment. The Supreme Court blocked broad executive forgiveness in 2023, and the courts then halted the SAVE plan, the most generous income-driven option. The budget law passed in July 2025 phases out SAVE and other plans and, for new loans from July 1, 2026, offers a new Repayment Assistance Plan with payments of roughly 1% to 10% of income, a minimum payment of $10 a month and forgiveness only after 30 years. Collections on defaulted loans, including wage garnishment, also resumed in 2025.

Interest keeps many balances high. Borrowers with large balances and modest incomes can find that payments barely cover the interest. Graduate borrowers in recent years faced federal rates of around 8% to 9%, and long periods of forbearance or deferment add interest to balances.

Future borrowing is being capped — which cuts both ways. The same 2025 law eliminated Graduate PLUS loans for new borrowers and set lifetime limits of $100,000 for most graduate programmes and $200,000 for professional degrees such as law and medicine. That should reduce extreme balances for future students, but it does nothing for the existing $1.7 trillion, and some students may turn to private loans with fewer protections.


What Could Happen

Debt keeps weighing on most borrowers Most Likely

Public service forgiveness and income-driven plans help some borrowers, but most continue repaying for years, defaults and damaged credit persist for millions, and the drag on homebuying, family formation and retirement saving continues through 2035. Borrowing caps gradually improve the picture for new students.

Affordable repayment becomes the effective standard Possible

The new repayment system proves simpler and more reliable than past programmes, automatic enrollment keeps payments tied to income, and defaults fall. Monthly burdens ease enough that the effects on major life decisions shrink, even though balances remain.

Broad forgiveness transforms the picture Less Likely

Congress passes large-scale forgiveness, wiping out a big share of the $1.7 trillion. Homebuying and saving among former borrowers jump. After the Supreme Court's 2023 ruling, only legislation could do this, and the current political direction makes it unlikely by 2035.

Our Assessment
We assign 72% probability that student debt continues to materially weigh on homeownership, family formation and retirement saving for most current borrowers through 2035. We have raised this forecast from 69%: since it was written, defaults have climbed past 9 million, delinquencies have hit credit scores, and the 2025 law replaced the most generous repayment plan with a stricter one. Research suggests the effect is real but moderate — debt delays homeownership rather than preventing it for most borrowers — and future borrowing caps should help the next generation of students.

What Can We Do

Person on a laptop researching student loan repayment options, income-driven repayment plan visible on screen

If you carry student debt, the most useful step is to understand your specific options, because the best strategy depends on your loan type, income and employer. This is general information, not personal financial advice.

Check which repayment plans you qualify for now. The rules changed in 2025 and 2026, and borrowers leaving the SAVE plan must choose a new one. Use the official tools on studentaid.gov, or contact your servicer, to compare income-driven plans and avoid missed payments.

If you are behind, act early. Default can lead to wage garnishment and seized tax refunds. Rehabilitation and consolidation programmes can bring defaulted loans back into good standing.

Check your eligibility for Public Service Loan Forgiveness. If you work for a government agency or qualifying nonprofit, you may be eligible for forgiveness after 10 years of qualifying payments. The PSLF Help Tool on studentaid.gov shows where you stand.

Do not give up retirement savings entirely. If your employer matches retirement contributions, that match is usually worth more than paying extra on a low-interest loan.

Stay engaged with the political process. Student loan policy is set by Congress and administered by the executive branch. The more than 40 million Americans with federal loans are a large group of voters, and policy changes when they make their views heard.