The Question
When Uber launched in 2009, its model was simple: classify drivers as independent contractors, not employees, and thereby avoid the costs of health insurance, unemployment contributions, workers' compensation, and paid leave. That model became the template for an entire sector. Upwork's 2023 Freelance Forward study estimated that 64 million Americans — 38% of the workforce — did some freelance work that year, earning about $1.27 trillion. Many do it on the side; a smaller group depends on it as their main income.
The specific question we are predicting: will federal legislation establish a system of portable benefits — benefits that attach to the worker rather than the employer, moving with them from gig to gig — by 2032? We put the probability at 25%. The idea has unusual cross-party appeal, and the platforms themselves now support it. But Congress has rarely passed major labour legislation in recent decades.
What the Evidence Shows
The human cost of the current system is real. Independent contractors are not covered by federal minimum wage and overtime rules, unemployment insurance, or workers' compensation, and they must arrange their own health insurance and retirement savings. The Affordable Care Act marketplace helps, but income from gig work is often volatile, making both premiums and savings hard to manage.
Meanwhile, the largest platforms have become very profitable. Uber's revenue reached about $52 billion in 2025, and DoorDash's about $13.7 billion. The argument that extending basic protections would destroy the platform economy has been tested — most directly in California, where voters approved Proposition 22 in 2020, keeping drivers as contractors while guaranteeing minimum earnings and some health stipends. The state's Supreme Court upheld it in 2024. The platforms adapted.
"President Trump’s Department of Labor has taken an important step to support a vital group of working Americans."
— Republican members of the Senate HELP Committee, led by Chairman Bill Cassidy, on the Labor Department's proposed independent-contractor rule, 2026The European Union moved first at scale. Its Platform Work Directive, adopted in 2024, creates a legal presumption that platform workers are employees unless platforms can prove otherwise — shifting the burden of proof. Member states must apply it by the end of 2026. The US is going in a different direction: rather than reclassifying workers, recent US proposals aim to let companies offer benefits without changing contractor status.
The gig economy was built on the idea that freedom from a boss was worth the loss of a safety net. It turns out, most workers never agreed to that trade.
Why This Is Happening
The gig workforce has reached political mass. Tens of millions of freelancers and contractors are spread across every congressional district. They include not just drivers and delivery workers but nurses, lawyers, software engineers, and journalists. That makes their benefits a bipartisan issue rather than a niche one.
The platforms now back portable benefits. For years, platforms argued that their margins could not absorb employment costs. Now profitable, DoorDash, Uber, and Instacart's parent have lobbied for state laws that let them contribute to benefits without making workers employees. DoorDash has run pilots in Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Georgia, contributing a share of drivers' earnings to benefit accounts.
State-level laws are creating a template. Utah passed the first portable benefits law in 2023, allowing companies to fund benefits while workers remain independent contractors. Tennessee and Alabama followed in 2025, and more states are considering similar bills. Separately, Washington state passed a 2022 law giving rideshare drivers minimum pay, paid sick time, and workers' compensation. In Congress, Senator Bill Cassidy introduced the Unlocking Benefits for Independent Workers Act in July 2025, creating a federal safe harbor for such benefits.
What Could Happen
Federal action stalls in a divided Congress. But states keep moving. By 2032, roughly 20 states have passed some form of portable benefits or minimum-earnings guarantee for gig workers. The result is a patchwork that protects roughly half the gig workforce to some degree — a significant improvement over the current nothing, but unequal and inconsistent. Platforms manage compliance state by state. A national law remains aspirational but does not arrive by 2032.
A bipartisan coalition — combining concern for worker protection with conservative interest in flexibility — passes a federal safe harbor and portable benefits framework, building on Senator Cassidy's 2025 bill and the state laws. This requires legislative time and agreement that has eluded Congress on labour issues.
Court rulings or regulatory action force reclassification of a significant share of gig workers as employees, triggering a rapid industry shift. Platforms absorb the costs, adjust their pricing and workforce size, and gig work becomes a smaller, better-protected sector. This scenario produces the strongest protections but eliminates the flexibility that many gig workers genuinely value. Less likely in the six-year window because platforms will litigate fiercely and have done so successfully.
What Can We Do
Until the law changes, gig workers are on their own. That is an unfair position — but there are ways to build protection within the current system.
Treat health insurance as a non-negotiable expense. The ACA marketplace offers subsidised coverage for lower-income self-employed workers that many gig workers qualify for and do not claim. Healthcare.gov's subsidy calculator shows what you would actually pay. For many full-time gig workers in moderate income brackets, monthly premiums are lower than expected.
Open a SEP-IRA or solo 401(k). Self-employed workers can contribute substantial amounts to retirement accounts — in 2025, up to $70,000 a year in a solo 401(k), depending on earnings. The tax benefits are significant, yet many gig workers never set these accounts up.
Build a personal emergency fund equivalent to three months of expenses. The income volatility of gig work makes this more critical than for traditional employees. Without an employer-backed unemployment system, self-insurance through savings is the only buffer against income disruption.
Follow your state's portable benefits debate. Many states are considering portable benefits bills, and their details matter — who contributes, how much, and whether workers can use the money for health insurance and retirement. Advocacy groups such as the Freelancers Union, and public comment on state bills, give independent workers a collective voice.
- Upwork — 64 million Americans freelanced in 2023, December 2023
- NCSL — States, employers weigh portable benefits for independent workers
- US Senate HELP Committee — Cassidy applauds Department of Labor efforts, encourages portable benefits, 2026
- Gray News — Sen. Bill Cassidy introduces portable benefits bill for gig workers, July 2025
- Motley Fool — Uber and DoorDash 2025 results, March 2026
- European Union — Directive (EU) 2024/2831 on improving working conditions in platform work, 2024