The Question

A modern smart home interior with ambient lighting and integrated sensors

Many people already live in a building that watches them. The Nest thermostat learns your schedule; the Ring doorbell records everyone who approaches; the Amazon Echo listens for its wake word; the Ecobee sensor tracks whether rooms are occupied. The first generation of smart home devices has been normalised so successfully that most users have stopped thinking about them.

The second generation is more capable — and more intimate. In 2018, researchers at MIT's Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory showed that their RF-Pose system could use radio signals to estimate people's postures through walls, without cameras; the same lab has used radio to track breathing and sleep. Google's Nest Hub uses a tiny Soli radar to track sleep from a bedside table. Vayyar Imaging sells radar sensors that detect falls in care homes. But not every product has survived: Amazon's Halo Rise, a radar sleep tracker, was discontinued in 2023 along with the rest of its Halo health line.

What the Evidence Shows

The "living building" concept has moved from architectural theory to commercial product. Platforms such as Samsung SmartThings, Google Home, and Apple Home, increasingly linked through the Matter standard, can automate lights, heating, and locks around occupants' routines. The question is not whether buildings are becoming more responsive, but how far it goes, and who controls the data.

At commercial scale the transformation is further advanced. Office buildings increasingly use occupancy sensors to adjust heating, cooling, and lighting. Alphabet's Sidewalk Labs planned a sensor-rich district on Toronto's Quayside waterfront, but cancelled it in 2020, citing economic uncertainty after a long controversy over privacy. Energy-efficient homes often carry sensors tracking air quality, carbon dioxide, humidity, and occupancy in enough detail to reveal a household's routine.

"Ring's disregard for privacy and security exposed consumers to spying and harassment."

— Samuel Levine, Director of the FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection, May 2023

Amazon's Sidewalk network, launched in 2021, is a low-bandwidth mesh created by Amazon Echo and Ring devices that extends connectivity to sensors in garages, gardens, and neighbourhoods. Devices joined by default, and owners had to opt out. Amazon says the network reaches about 90% of the US population. It shows how quickly home devices can be turned into a shared sensing infrastructure that most participants barely notice.

A home that saves energy, predicts maintenance failures, and calls for help when you fall is a good thing. A home that reports everything you do to your insurer, your landlord, and your government is a different thing entirely.

Why This Is Happening

The energy efficiency imperative is driving sensor deployment at scale. Meeting net-zero targets requires buildings to optimize energy with a precision timers and manual controls cannot achieve. Real-time occupancy sensing, predictive heating and cooling, and grid demand-response all require the same dense, continuous monitoring that can track human behavior in intimate detail. The climate argument is genuine; the surveillance capability is simply a by-product of those sensors.

Ageing populations are creating demand for ambient health monitoring. In Japan, South Korea, Germany, and Italy, a building that monitors elderly occupants for falls and changes in routine can be a public health tool rather than a privacy threat. Japan has about 36 million people aged 65 or over, many living alone. Radar that detects a fall and summons help without a wearable is a genuinely humane technology — and eldercare is where these sensors are spreading first.

Insurance, real estate, and finance see the data as valuable. The behavioural data a responsive building generates — time spent at home, which rooms you use and when, your sleep and visitors — is the kind of information insurers and landlords would value. Some insurers already offer discounts for leak and smoke sensors. Each such use creates an incentive to collect more data, independent of any benefit to the occupant. Misuse is not hypothetical: in 2023, Amazon's Ring paid $5.8 million to settle US Federal Trade Commission charges that employees and contractors had been able to access customers' private videos.


What Could Happen

Living buildings become standard with minimal privacy protection Unlikely · 20%

Responsive, health-sensing buildings become standard in new construction across the developed world, driven by efficiency mandates, eldercare demand, and real estate optimisation. Regulation lags deployment, and home data flows to insurers and landlords under terms residents cannot practically negotiate.

Strong data sovereignty laws create a two-tier market Most likely · 50%

Basic smart features — learning thermostats, occupancy sensors, smart locks — become common, while continuous health and behaviour monitoring remains an optional add-on used mainly in eldercare. Data rules diverge: Europe's GDPR treats health data as specially protected, while protections elsewhere are weaker.

Public backlash leads to meaningful opt-out rights Possible · 30%

A high-profile incident — an insurer using home monitoring data to deny a claim, a landlord evicting a tenant on behavioral data, or police accessing home sensor records without a warrant — triggers enough public outrage to produce a meaningful legislative response. Strong opt-out rights are established across major markets, and buildings must disclose all data collection in plain language. The technology keeps deploying, but with genuine informed consent that substantially changes how data flows from home to corporate and government entities.

Our Assessment
We assign 20% probability — unlikely that intelligently responsive buildings — tracking occupancy, health signals, and behavioral patterns in real time — become standard in new residential construction within a decade. We have lowered this forecast from 68%. Our earlier version misdescribed several products and research projects and cited a quote we could not verify. The technology is real: radar sleep sensing, fall detection, and occupancy-driven heating all exist. But consumer health-sensing devices have had a mixed record, and builders adopt new technology slowly. Basic smart-home features in many new homes, with continuous health monitoring mainly in eldercare, is the likelier outcome.

What Can We Do

A person reviewing smart home privacy settings on a phone

The living building is coming. Whether it serves its occupants or surveils them — whether its data enriches the people who live in it or the corporations that insure, rent, and finance it — depends on decisions being made now, before the infrastructure is built and the norms are set.

Audit what your home is already doing. Most people with Nest, Ring, Ecobee, Amazon Echo, or Google Home devices have agreed — in terms of service they did not read — to data collection they may not intend. Mozilla's "Privacy Not Included" guide is an accessible starting point.

Opt out of ambient data networks actively, not passively. Features such as Amazon Sidewalk were switched on by default and require deliberate action to disable. Defaults tend to maximise data collection, so an hour checking your device settings is time well spent.

Demand data portability and deletion rights from building managers. If you rent, your landlord may already be collecting occupancy and behavioral data from smart building systems. In many jurisdictions you can request what has been collected, receive a copy, and demand deletion — and exercising these rights, even when inconvenient, pressures operators to take data governance seriously and sets precedents protecting all residents.

Engage with smart city planning in your community. Deploying smart building infrastructure in public housing, transit hubs, and commercial districts is a planning and zoning decision subject, in principle, to public input — but in practice often made without it. Attending planning meetings, responding to consultations, and supporting privacy-by-design advocacy are concrete ways to shape how this technology is deployed.