The Question

Chimpanzee looking directly at camera in a sanctuary setting

In December 2014, an Argentine appeals court described Sandra, an orangutan who had spent most of her life in the Buenos Aires Zoo, as a "non-human subject" with some rights. In 2015, a Buenos Aires judge went further and declared her a "non-human person". Sandra was eventually moved to the Center for Great Apes sanctuary in Wauchula, Florida, in 2019.

In 2016, a judge in Mendoza granted a writ of habeas corpus — the ancient legal protection against unlawful detention — to Cecilia, a chimpanzee held alone in a concrete enclosure, and ordered her transfer to a great ape sanctuary in Sorocaba, Brazil. These cases are real milestones. But they came from civil-law courts in Latin America, and their reach elsewhere has been limited.

What the Evidence Shows

In the United States, the Nonhuman Rights Project, founded by attorney Steven Wise, has filed habeas corpus petitions for chimpanzees and elephants. All have failed. In 2018, New York's highest court declined to hear the cases of the chimpanzees Tommy and Kiko, though Judge Eugene Fahey wrote a concurring opinion urging courts to take the question of animal personhood seriously. In 2022, the same court ruled 5–2 that Happy, an elephant at the Bronx Zoo, could not use habeas corpus because it is a remedy for human beings. Two judges dissented, one calling Happy's captivity "an affront to a civilized society".

The global picture is broader. In 2017, New Zealand granted legal personhood to the Whanganui River, recognising it as an ancestor of the Māori people. Ecuador's constitution has recognised the rights of nature since 2008, and in 2022 its Constitutional Court ruled, in the case of a woolly monkey called Estrellita, that individual wild animals are protected as subjects of rights. India's Supreme Court held in 2014 that animals' right to life falls under Article 21 of the constitution. Spain changed its civil code in 2021 to recognise animals as sentient beings rather than things, and the UK's Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022 extended recognition of sentience to octopuses, crabs, and lobsters.

"The question is not, Can they reason? nor, Can they talk? but, Can they suffer?"

— Jeremy Bentham, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789), quoted by Peter Singer in Animal Liberation

The Naruto case — PETA's copyright lawsuit on behalf of a macaque that took a selfie with a photographer's camera — was dismissed by the Ninth Circuit in 2018 because the Copyright Act does not give animals the right to sue. The court did not say animals can never have legal standing; it said this statute did not confer it.

We already give legal rights to corporations, rivers, and ships. The question is not whether non-human entities can hold rights — they can. The question is which ones, and why not animals?

Why This Is Happening

The science of animal cognition has transformed. Elephants and some apes pass the mirror self-recognition test. Bottlenose dolphins use signature whistles that work like names. Crows use tools and recognise individual human faces. The Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness (2012) stated that many non-human animals possess the neurological substrates of conscious experience, and in 2024 the New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness, signed by dozens of scientists and philosophers, found strong support for consciousness in mammals and birds and a "realistic possibility" of it in all vertebrates and many invertebrates.

The legal infrastructure is already being built. Animal law is now taught at well over 100 US law schools, up from a handful in the 1990s. Advocacy groups such as the Animal Legal Defense Fund litigate to enforce welfare laws, and many US states now let courts include pets in domestic violence protective orders. Taking animal interests seriously in court is expanding even where formal rights have not been granted.

Factory farming is creating a crisis of moral contradiction. The same societies that prosecute dog-fighting with felony charges confine billions of pigs, chickens, and cattle in conditions of extreme restriction and suffering. This contradiction is becoming increasingly visible — and increasingly uncomfortable for courts, legislators, and citizens who consider themselves animal lovers. The gap between how people feel about their pets and how the food industry treats farm animals is a gap that animal rights advocates are driving a legal wedge into, with growing success.


What Could Happen

A major common-law court grants limited legal personhood to a great ape or cetacean by 2033 Possible · 30%

Building on the Latin American precedents and the dissents in the Happy case, a court in the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, or Australia — or a legislature — grants a great ape, elephant, or cetacean limited legal personhood, such as the right not to be arbitrarily confined. The decision creates a new category between property and person.

A treaty or international convention establishes minimum rights for great apes Less likely · 10%

The Great Ape Project — founded by philosophers Peter Singer and Paola Cavalieri in 1993 — has long called for a United Nations declaration of rights for great apes. A binding international instrument remains distant, though a non-binding framework could prompt national laws.

The movement overreaches and triggers a backlash that sets rights recognition back Possible · 20%

A court ruling or legislative proposal that appears to threaten livestock agriculture or pet ownership — for example, a ruling that farm animals have a right not to be killed — triggers a massive political backlash, industry-funded constitutional amendments in agricultural states, and a decade-long retrenchment. Animal rights organisations have generally avoided this trap by focusing on captive great apes and cetaceans rather than farm animals, but a strategic misstep remains possible.

Our Assessment
We assign 30% probability — possible that at least one major common-law jurisdiction will formally recognise some form of legal personhood or standing for great apes, cetaceans, or elephants within ten years. We have lowered this forecast from 61%. Our earlier version contained factual errors about the Argentine and New York cases and misattributed a famous quote. The momentum is real — Ecuador's court, new sentience laws in Spain and the UK, and the dissents in the Happy case — but every habeas corpus petition in the US has failed, and common-law courts prefer to leave such changes to legislatures. Stronger welfare laws are far likelier than formal personhood.

What Can We Do

Elephants in natural habitat demonstrating complex social behaviour

The question of animal rights has immediate, practical policy dimensions. The decisions made in the next decade will shape the legal status of the natural world for generations.

Support targeted legislation for the most cognitively complex animals. Great apes, cetaceans, and elephants represent the strongest scientific case for legal personhood. Focused advocacy for laws limiting their use in entertainment and research builds momentum without triggering the agricultural backlash that broader rights claims risk.

Strengthen and enforce existing welfare laws. In most jurisdictions, animal cruelty laws are chronically under-enforced due to lack of resources and prosecutorial priority. Improving enforcement of laws already on the books would prevent enormous suffering and build institutional capacity for the next step without requiring new legislation.

Fund cognitive science and ethology research. The legal case for animal rights depends partly on the scientific case for animal cognition. The stronger and more publicly understood that case becomes, the harder it is for courts and legislatures to treat animals as mere property.

Engage the farming industry in transition planning early. If legal rights for some animals are coming regardless, the farming industry's interests are better served by participating in the design of a transition framework than by opposing the entire concept. Agricultural producers who participate in early discussions about what rights-based regulation of farm animal welfare might look like will have more influence over the outcome than those who simply resist.